Why Marquise Diamonds Are Secretly a Scam (But Also Kind of Genius)

So, you’re thinking about a marquise diamond engagement ring? Oh, honey. Let’s talk about this controversial choice before you make a potentially huge mistake. Some people adore the elongated, vintage-meets-royalty aesthetic. Others? They see a glorified blinged-out football.

Are you ready to risk getting side-eyes from your judgmental cousin and endless unsolicited opinions? Buckle up.

What is a Marquise Diamond? (Besides Highly Polarizing)

The marquise diamond has been causing debates since the 1700s. King Louis XV of France supposedly commissioned a diamond shaped like his mistress’s lips (because nothing says romance like immortalizing someone’s mouth in expensive carbon).

Fast forward to today, and this dramatic, pointy oval is either a bold fashion statement or a questionable design choice—depending on who you ask.

BUT WAIT—there are some good things about it, too.

• It looks bigger than it actually is (because who doesn’t love getting more for less?).
• It elongates the fingers, making them look elegant and slender.
• It’s not basic—you won’t see this on every other bride flashing their hand on Instagram.

Speaking of diamonds, if you’re looking for a more sustainable and ethical choice, check out lab-grown diamonds in Atlanta, GA—because guilt-free sparkle is always a win.

Why Marquise Diamonds Are Secretly a Scam (But Also Kind of Genius)

Let’s be real: Marquise diamonds are deceptively large-looking. A 1-carat marquise has about 15% more surface area than a round diamond. That means:

✔ You get more diamond for your dollar (great for flexing on a budget).
✔ It creates a vintage, aristocratic vibe (think old-money elegance).
✔ It makes small hands look gracefully elongated (goodbye, stubby fingers).

But Here’s The Catch…

❌ The Bow-Tie Effect: Many marquise diamonds suffer from this unfortunate shadowy area in the center, making it look like your diamond has a built-in tuxedo. Cute? Maybe. Ideal? Not really.

❌ Sharp Tips = Disaster Waiting to Happen: Those delicate, pointed ends love to chip, snag, and generally make life difficult. If you tend to accidentally karate-chop furniture, consider a safer cut.

❌ Not Everyone “Gets It”: This is not a mainstream diamond cut. Some people will judge you. Are they wrong? Probably. Will they still do it? Absolutely.

The Worst Thing About Marquise Diamonds (That Might Actually Be Their Best Feature)

There’s one undeniable fact about marquise diamond engagement rings—they aren’t safe choices.

If you’re looking for a basic, everyone-approves, no-controversy ring, this is NOT it.

But if you:
✔ Love standing out from the crowd.
✔ Want a bigger-looking diamond without paying extra.
✔ Appreciate vintage-inspired, regal aesthetics.

Then congratulations, you’re the kind of person who can actually pull off a marquise diamond.

Still Unsure? Read This Before You Regret Everything

Choosing a marquise diamond is one thing. Picking the right metal for it is another. If you're torn between white gold and yellow gold, don’t make a decision before reading this guide—because metal choice matters.

And if you still need convincing (or just want to admire some jaw-dropping designs), check out this list of stunning marquise engagement rings from the experts at Brides.

Final Verdict: Should You Buy a Marquise Diamond?

Honestly? Probably not… unless you actually have style.

If you want something unique, vintage-chic, and sneakily big-looking, go for it. Just be prepared to defend your choice against the round-diamond loyalists.

If you’d rather play it safe, stick to a round or oval cut and enjoy blending in with the crowd.

Daring Enough for a Marquise?

Make an appointment today to browse our selection of marquise diamond engagement rings that will either make you a trendsetter or a scandal—your choice.